 |
The
2003 HODRW |
|
|
The
2003 HODRW |
A. First, write the book titles and authors of this panel on this score
sheet.
B. Next, please read each book from beginning to end.
C. Then, score each book on its own merit according to Scoring Guidelines
below.
NOTE: There is no limit to how many novels may receive the highest/lowest
scores.
D. Finally, rank each book in order of preference – 1 being the best, 5
being the least favorite.
Scoring guidelines:
1 – Outstanding This book has touched me emotionally and left me
wanting more. This book is a keeper.
2 – Great A really good read with that something special that
lifted it out of the ordinary.
3 – Good This book is entertaining and solidly-written.
4 – Fair This book lacks that extra spark I hope for in a romance.
5 – Not a Romance This book lacks qualities this reader looks for
in a romance.
Title Author Score 1-5 Rank 1-5
_____________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________
Judge # _______ Judge’s signature (optional) ______________________________
Judge’s bio: Pre-published ___ Published fiction ____ Published non-fiction ____Reader ____